Music and Lyrics by William Finn
Conceived by Rebecca Feldman
From the book by Rachel Sheinkin
Additional materials by Jay Reiss
The Cast
(In order of appearance)
| Chip Tolentino/Jesus | Vince Mirabile |
| Schwarzy/Leaf's Mom | Agata Sokolska |
| Leaf Coneybear/Carl Dad | John Eidman |
|
Marcy Park
|
Gabriella Giuliano |
| Olive Ostrovsky | Caitlin Eriser |
| Rona Lisa Peretti/Olive's Mom | Carrie Van Tol |
| Douglas Panch | Terence Van Auken |
|
Mitch Mahoney/Dan Dad
|
Peter Gutierrez |
|
Mitch Mahoney Understudy
|
Valerie Betts |
| William Barfee/Olive's Dad | Beau Wade |
Produced through special arrangement with Music Theatre International (MTI)